By Gary Smith
These and other questions are of concern to novice and experienced traders alike – and we want to help you answer them.
Binaryoptions.co.uk is committed to providing our readers with a definitive and up-to-date picture of binary options trading in the UK. Being clued up on tax is part of this, which is why we’ve made direct enquiries with HMRC to bring you this guide to binary options and UK tax, which can then be used to help you make your own assessment of your trading activity. Links to relevant official guidelines are also included.
HMRC looks at all relevant circumstances to make decisions on tax liability. Here, we’ll outline the position on how the tax authorities tend to regard binary options. However, it is important to note that the correct treatment of any financial transaction or investment comes down to a question of fact:
A transaction with a spread betting firm is a good example of this contextual approach; i.e. speculating on whether an asset will rise or fall. For most individuals, HMRC is likely to consider this activity as betting, which means any profits made from it will be outside the scope of both Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax. However, if that same transaction is carried out for commercial purposes; (for instance, if it is made strategically as a hedge to offset the risks attached to direct investment in a security), any profits that arises from it might be regarded as part of a wider pattern of activity attracting tax liability. For more information on this, see guidance note BIM56880.
Common terms have very specific meanings when dealing with tax.
You may consider yourself as a ‘trader’, but HMRC will not regard you as such if the activity you are involved in consists solely of speculative transactions. The consequence of purely speculative, gambling or betting activity is that profitable transactions from it do not generally attract a tax charge. However, the potential downside of this from your point of view is that you cannot claim tax relief on losses from this type of activity. For more official guidance on the meaning of ‘trade, see guidance notes BIM20050-20110.
HMRC would also take issue with the description of ‘binary options’ as ‘options’ in the formal sense. An option, in the eyes of HMRC, is an agreed right to buy or sell an underlying asset at a specified price within a specified timeframe. It tends to have an inherent value in itself (which carries CGT implications). If you see any reference to tax treatment of ‘options’, bear in mind that it is not referring to binary options. See CG12300 for the formal definition.
Binary options present individuals with the opportunity to benefit from fluctuations up or down in, for instance, the price of individual shares or the performance of indices such as stock markets or currency markets. These are derivative products; which means you do not have any ownership in the underlying asset (at no point do you own the share in question, for instance).
In fact, there are only two possible outcomes once the option expires: a fixed amount of money or nothing, depending on which direction you have bet. HMRC will almost always regard this as a form of gambling: a speculative activity that does not in itself give rise to CGT or IT liability.
Cases that have gone before the courts help to shed light on this. The official guidance note BIM22017 refers to the case of Graham v Green  9TC309. Here, it was shown that even if a gambler has expertise and has a well-worked ‘system’ in place, this does not mean that they are engaged in a trade.
A more recent case Hakki v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions  EWCA Civ 530 concerned a professional poker player who made a living through his winnings and who was facing a child maintenance payment order from the Child Support Agency. The Court of Appeal once again confirmed the general principle that gambling is not a trade.
So even if your only source of income is from binary options profits, it seems unlikely at present that profits would be deemed liable for tax. But do not rule it out completely. To adapt an analogy provided in the guidance notes, If, for instance, you receive financial reward for providing customers with binary options trading hints and tips, “whether or not [your] gambling winnings are proceeds of that trade would depend on the facts”.
The answer, in the majority of cases, is likely to be no as it is not classed as income for tax purposes. But as ever with tax, it all depends on the context. Use this general guidance and consider your position carefully. An accountant with specific expertise in gambling and financial trading activities should be able to assess your particular circumstances and provide an opinion on potential liabilities.
Looking for a reliable, reputable platform to conduct your binary options trades? Check out our no-nonsense reviews of the best sites.